Discover and Recover

Softening strict requirement of optimality can make problems tractable. Put it another way it is more important to quickly narrow the search for an optimal solution to a “good enough” subset than to calculate the “perfect solution.” Ordinal (which is better) before Cardinal (value of optimum).
Compare the two scenarios presented below:

  1. Getting the best decision for certain – Cost = $1m
  2. Cost = $1m/x – Getting a decision within the top 5% With probability = 0.99*

In real life, we often settle for such a tradeoff with x=100 to 10,000

For systems that are not life-threatening, the focus should be on fast fault detection and mitigation (discover and recover) instead of exhaustively trying out every possible scenario which will make the system perfect but at such a cost that forward progress turns glacially slow. At which point your quicker, nimbler opponents will run over you with their faster product cycles.

People constantly deceive themselves into thinking that by paying much more they are getting a 100% solution but in reality you never get a true 100% solution, so its really a choice between different levels of less than perfect.

*Under independent sampling, variance decreases as 1/sqrt(n). Each order of magnitude increase in certainty requires 2 orders of magnitude increase in sampling cost. To go from p=0.99 to certainty (p=0.99999) implies a 1,000,000 fold increase in sampling cost.


Cardinal vs Ordinal work by Dr. Yu-Chi Ho

Satisficing (wikipedia)


One Response to Discover and Recover

  1. Greg says:

    I’ve had discussions recently that made me consider how fear drives some people to ignore probability, and then to incur additional cost/complexity to solve for improbable scenarios. Especially once improbable scenario (A) has occurred, fear drives the invalid conclusion that P(A)=1.00, and the subsequent decision to defer current work in order to prevent recurrence of (A). Obviously, not referring to cases where (A) is caused deliberately.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: